Difference Is Not Deficiency — Inspiring Edition

Listen to this article (BETA)

Preparing the reader…

Your progress: Not started

Mark Complete Start Over Reset History

▶ Listen

Several years ago, my bride and I attended a certification course on personality and marriage. Approximately fifty couples were in the room, all learning how personality affects communication, conflict, expectations, affection, decisions, and nearly every other part of marriage—including how two people can hear the same sentence and somehow leave the conversation with entirely different transcripts.

My wife and I had the greatest personality difference of any couple there.

I am 100 Inspiring and 97 Dominant. I am highly Outgoing, fast-paced, expressive, optimistic, spontaneous, enthusiastic, and usually ready to tell you what I am thinking—sometimes while I am still discovering what it is.

My bride is 100 Conscientious and 100 Supportive. She is Reserved, careful, patient, consistent, thoughtful, precise, and generally prefers that all relevant facts be located, examined, alphabetized, and placed in protective sleeves before anyone touches anything.

On a standard four-direction DISC circle, our profiles are approximately 179.13 degrees apart on a 180-degree scale.

We were not simply opposites. Apparently, the Lord knew the full 180 degrees might violate local building codes.

During that certification course, something happened that changed the way my wife understood me.

The instructor’s personality was remarkably similar to mine. As she listened to him teach, watched how he communicated, and recognized his behavioral patterns, she had an epiphany. Some of the things she had interpreted as personal defects in me were recognizable personality tendencies in him.

She did not conclude that everything I had ever done was right. It was not. I had several character problems available for immediate inspection. What she realized was that not everything she disliked about me meant I was selfish, careless, immature, or deliberately trying to make her life difficult.

Some of it was simply difference.

She realized that the toad she had married was not necessarily a mean, evil, nasty toad. Some of his more toad-like qualities came from a personality profoundly different from hers. Somewhere along the line, kissing the toad didn’t turn me into a prince, but it did make me less green…

Understanding did not excuse my behavior. It changed the starting point from which she interpreted it.

There is an enormous difference between saying, “My spouse behaves differently from me,” and saying, “My spouse behaves wrongly because my spouse does not behave like me.”

That difference can change the atmosphere of a marriage.

---

We Naturally Believe Love Should Look Like Us

Every person lives inside his or her own personality. Our natural pace, emotional expression, need for interaction, tolerance for risk, and approach to decisions simply feel normal.

The problem is that normal gradually becomes correct.

For an Inspiring personality, love usually feels expressive, responsive, relational, enthusiastic, and emotionally present. We talk. We share. We laugh. We tell stories. We ask questions. We want to know what happened, what you thought about it, how you felt about it, and whether you noticed the amusing thing that occurred while everything else was happening.

When we love people, we move toward them.

Therefore, when our spouse becomes quiet, asks for time, responds without much emotion, focuses on the facts, or does not match our enthusiasm, we may not merely experience difference.

We may experience rejection.

“They do not want to talk to me.”

“They are not excited about what matters to me.”

“They do not enjoy being with me.”

“They do not care how I feel.”

“They must be angry.”

“They do not love me as much as I love them.”

Those conclusions can feel completely true.

They may also be completely wrong.

Your spouse may love you deeply and still need quiet.

Your spouse may care about your feelings without expressing emotion as visibly as you do.

Your spouse may enjoy your story without responding to every portion of it.

Your spouse may need time to think before answering.

Your spouse may be tired rather than angry, processing rather than withdrawing, and careful rather than unresponsive.

Different expression is not necessarily diminished love.

Difference is not deficiency.

[We use The DISC Model of Human Behavior when talking about personality. It is a simple way of understanding the four primary patterns of personality: Dominant, Inspiring, Supportive, and Conscientious (spelling DISC). It considers a person’s Pace—whether Outgoing or Reserved—and Compass—whether primarily Task-oriented or People-oriented—to help explain how people naturally communicate, make decisions, approach work, and respond to others. Most people display a blend of all four patterns, with one or two usually appearing more strongly. DISC describes observable tendencies, not ability, maturity, or character, and it helps us understand how someone may naturally behave, but never excuses how anyone chooses to behave.]

Personality has nothing to do with intelligence. A person with any DISC personality can possess a very high IQ, extraordinary insight, or exceptional ability.

Conscientious personalities may sometimes appear more intelligent because they tend to think before speaking, examine the details, verify their conclusions, and present their thoughts carefully.

Inspiring personalities are often processing just as rapidly, but some of that processing may escape through their mouths before passing final inspection.

We may speak in order to discover what we think. A quieter person may think in order to decide what to speak.

One process is external. The other is internal.

One is not necessarily more intelligent than the other. They simply do not sound alike while the thinking is happening.

A Quiet Response Is Still a Response

Inspiring personalities naturally read people. We notice facial expressions, tone of voice, energy, responsiveness, and relational movement.

That awareness can be a wonderful gift. It helps us connect, encourage, engage, and recognize when someone needs attention.

It can also create problems when we interpret every signal through our own emotional expectations.

A shorter answer becomes displeasure.

A delayed answer becomes avoidance.

A flat tone becomes anger.

A need for solitude becomes rejection.

A request for facts becomes distrust.

A cautious response becomes negativity.

Sometimes we are reading the room accurately.

Sometimes we are writing an entire emotional screenplay from one raised eyebrow.

The Reserved spouse may not be withholding love. The Reserved spouse may simply not display thoughts and feelings as quickly or visibly.

The Task-oriented spouse may not be dismissing you. That spouse may be attempting to understand the problem before discussing the emotions surrounding it.

The careful spouse may not be trying to crush your idea. That spouse may be identifying something that could protect the idea from failure.

The decisive spouse may not be trying to ignore your feelings. That spouse may believe solving the problem is the most loving response available.

You may need more connection than your spouse naturally provides. That need should be communicated. Marriage requires both people to adapt.

But do not decide what your spouse’s behavior means before asking.

Your feelings are real. Your interpretation of those feelings may not be accurate.

Personality and Character Are Not the Same Thing

Personality describes how someone naturally tends to behave.

Character reveals whether someone behaves truthfully, lovingly, responsibly, and faithfully.

An Inspiring person may communicate with enthusiasm. Enthusiasm is personality. Exaggeration, manipulation, or dishonesty involves character.

A Dominant person may communicate directly. Directness is personality. Cruelty is character.

A Supportive person may prefer harmony. A desire for peace is personality. Dishonesty, concealed resentment, or passive aggression involves character.

A Conscientious person may need accuracy and order. Carefulness is personality. Contempt, control, and impossible standards involve character.

Do not demand that your spouse repent for being different.

Do not allow your spouse to call sin a personality difference.

That is the line couples must learn to see.

“Why don’t you talk as much as I do?” may be an accusation against personality.

“Why did you refuse to communicate for three days in order to punish me?” addresses character.

“Why aren’t you more enthusiastic?” may be an accusation against personality.

“Why do you continually belittle the things that matter to me?” addresses character.

“Why do you need so much information?” may be an accusation against personality.

“Why did you continue delaying a necessary decision after the facts were known?” addresses responsibility.

“Why do I always have to tell you how I feel?” may reveal a difference in emotional expression.

“Why do you repeatedly ignore what I have clearly communicated?” may reveal selfishness.

The question is not merely, “Did this hurt my feelings?”

The better questions are, “What actually happened? What did my spouse intend? Is this behavior contrary to Scripture, or is it primarily contrary to my preference?”

That does not mean feelings are irrelevant. Feelings tell us that something inside us requires attention.

They do not always tell us the truth about someone else.

Your Strength Can Become the Problem

Inspiring personalities possess wonderful strengths.

Enthusiasm.

Optimism.

Communication.

Creativity.

Warmth.

Spontaneity.

The ability to encourage people and help them see possibilities.

We can bring energy into a room, hope into discouragement, and connection into relationships that have become mechanical.

Those same strengths can create problems when they are not governed by character.

Enthusiasm can become exaggeration.

Optimism can become denial.

Spontaneity can become irresponsibility.

Communication can become gossip.

Persuasion can become manipulation.

A desire for affirmation can become approval addiction.

Relational warmth can become inappropriate emotional intimacy.

Starting exciting things can become abandoning ordinary commitments.

Your greatest weakness may not be the opposite of your greatest strength. It may be your greatest strength without restraint.

The goal is not to suppress the personality God has given you. Your spouse does not need you to become silent, colorless, restrained, and suspiciously interested in spreadsheets.

The goal is to steward your personality in love.

A mature Inspiring person learns to say:

“My enthusiasm does not make every idea wise.”

“My feelings do not make every interpretation accurate.”

“My intentions do not erase the effect of my actions.”

“My apology requires follow-through.”

“My need for affirmation does not entitle me to seek it from inappropriate places.”

“My promises still matter after the excitement has passed.”

Personality supplies the energy. Character determines where that energy goes.

God Did Not Make Every Member Expressive

Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 12, “For the body does not consist of one part, but of many.”

The eye cannot say to the hand, “I do not need you.”

Yet spouses do this regularly.

The expressive spouse says, “I do not need your quietness.”

The spontaneous spouse says, “I do not need your caution.”

The optimistic spouse says, “I do not need your questions.”

The relational spouse says, “I do not need your focus on the task.”

What we often mean is, “I want you to bring your strengths to this marriage, but I would prefer that those strengths arrive dressed like mine.”

That is not how bodies work, and it is not how marriages work.

Your spouse’s caution may protect you from a commitment you cannot sustain.

Your spouse’s focus may turn one of your possibilities into something real.

Your spouse’s patience may provide the stability needed to finish what enthusiasm began.

Your spouse’s directness may tell you a truth that approval-seeking friends would avoid.

The very difference that frustrates you may be one of God’s provisions for you.

Your spouse does not need to cheer as loudly as you do in order to stand beside you faithfully.

Your spouse does not need to tell the story the way you would in order to remember that it matters.

Your spouse does not need to express love in your natural language alone.

God did not make your spouse different from you because He ran out of Inspiring personalities.

Your differences were not a manufacturing error.

Difference is not deficiency.

When Opposites Exist Within One Person

Sometimes opposing personality patterns exist within the same person.

The Inspiring and Conscientious patterns sit opposite each other. One is Outgoing and People-oriented. The other is Reserved and Task-oriented.

One naturally expresses, connects, improvises, and responds.

The other naturally analyzes, restrains, verifies, and protects against error.

When both patterns are strong, the person may feel as though two entirely different responses are available.

An I/C may be socially confident, energetic, expressive, and engaging. Under stress, that same person may withdraw, become intensely analytical, guarded, critical, emotionally contained, or overwhelmed by the possibility of error.

A C/I may usually appear careful and controlled but become highly verbal, emotional, reactive, or approval-seeking when pressure rises.

The other spouse becomes confused.

“I thought I knew who you were. Why are you behaving like an entirely different person?”

The person has not necessarily developed a different personality. Stress may have activated another strong but opposing part of the existing blend.

After noticing this pattern in several divorcing couples, I began looking for it more intentionally. Over approximately fifteen years, among the couples in whom I personally observed a strong I/C or C/I pattern, only one remains married.

That is not a controlled empirical study. It does not prove that an I/C or C/I blend causes divorce. It is my continuing personal observation, and the number of couples is limited. However, I have seen the pattern often enough to consider it a responsible working theory.

The danger is not the blend itself.

The danger is unmanaged confusion.

The Inspiring side wants connection, expression, acceptance, freedom, and possibility.

The Conscientious side wants control, accuracy, restraint, certainty, and protection from error.

One side says, “Talk about it now.”

The other says, “Do not speak until you know exactly what to say.”

One side says, “They must still love me.”

The other says, “Let us review every available piece of evidence.”

One side wants to move closer.

The other builds a small analytical bunker and asks everyone to remain outside until further notice.

Understanding the pattern provides language for what is happening. It does not excuse harmful behavior, but it allows the couple to stop treating every shift as fraud, manipulation, instability, or rejection.

Ask:

What activates the shift?

What does it feel like internally?

What does the other spouse see externally?

How can the person explain what is happening before withdrawing or reacting?

What response provides connection without increasing pressure?

Which behaviors require understanding, and which require repentance?

Knowledge replaces some of the fear. Language replaces some of the confusion. Responsibility replaces some of the accusation.

Personality Creates Pressure; Character Makes the Choice

No personality has exclusive ownership of any sin. Every personality can be proud, selfish, dishonest, unfaithful, angry, controlling, resentful, or irresponsible.

Personality may help explain the form temptation takes. It never removes responsibility for the choice.

An Inspiring personality may desire greater physical intimacy than a spouse, but personality does not cause adultery. Choosing an affair is sin.

An Inspiring personality may enjoy attention and affirmation, but personality does not cause flirtation or emotional unfaithfulness. Seeking improper intimacy outside the marriage is a character choice.

An Inspiring personality may process thoughts aloud, but personality does not cause gossip. Repeating confidential or damaging information is sin.

An Inspiring personality may communicate with enthusiasm, but personality does not cause lying. Exaggerating facts, altering the story to gain approval, or making promises one has no intention of keeping is a character problem.

An Inspiring personality may seek acceptance, but personality does not cause manipulation. Using charm, emotion, affection, withdrawal, or spiritual language to control someone is sin.

An Inspiring personality may become excited about new possibilities, but personality does not cause irresponsibility. Abandoning commitments whenever something more interesting appears is a failure of faithfulness.

Feeling neglected, criticized, misunderstood, or unloved does not cause retaliation.

Feeling rejected does not authorize unfaithfulness.

Feeling unheard does not justify speaking carelessly.

Feeling controlled does not excuse breaking a promise.

Personality may explain why a temptation feels powerful, why a response comes quickly, or why a sinful pattern takes a particular form.

It cannot convert sin into a personality difference.

Personality describes the pressure. Character is revealed in the choice.

What an Inspiring Spouse Should Do

Begin by slowing down long enough to separate what happened from what you felt about what happened.

Ask:

What did my spouse actually say?

What meaning did I add?

Did my spouse reject me, or did my spouse simply respond differently than I hoped?

Am I asking my spouse to love me well, or am I requiring my spouse to love me exactly as I would?

Have I communicated my need clearly, or have I expected my spouse to recognize it from the atmosphere?

Have I kept the promises I made when I was enthusiastic?

Have I apologized repeatedly for something I have not seriously attempted to change?

Then act.

Tell your spouse what you need without accusation.

Allow your spouse time to process.

Ask what the silence means instead of deciding what it means.

Do not fill every quiet space.

Listen through the entire answer without preparing your next story.

When you make a commitment, write it down.

When the excitement fades, remain faithful.

When your spouse raises a concern, do not immediately recruit an audience, build a supporting cast, or retell the story until everyone agrees you were right.

Protect confidential information.

Guard the emotional boundaries of your marriage.

Do not seek from another person the affirmation, attention, or intimacy you should be cultivating with your spouse.

Your need for connection is real. Your spouse’s need for quiet, accuracy, stability, or space may also be real.

Love makes room for both.

Why Understanding Can Open the Heart

After Scripture, personality assessment has been the most useful tool I have seen for helping couples understand one another.

That does not mean DISC is more authoritative, truthful, or powerful than God’s Word. Scripture alone reveals God’s truth, exposes the heart, identifies sin, defines love, and directs us toward Christ.

But people do not always want to follow Scripture.

We may hear, “Bear with one another,” while remaining convinced that our spouse would no longer require forbearance if that spouse would simply become more loving, expressive, responsive, enthusiastic, and—if we are being honest—a little more like us.

Personality understanding can soften that defense.

It helps us consider, perhaps for the first time:

“My spouse may not be rejecting me.”

“My spouse may not be angry.”

“My spouse may not be withholding love.”

“My spouse may simply be different.”

Once the accusation softens, Scripture can address the heart more directly.

DISC can explain the difference and soften the heart. Scripture reveals what love requires and transforms the person.

The assessment provides language for what is happening. God’s Word tells us what faithfulness requires. The assessment may help us identify our natural tendencies. The Spirit of God changes how we steward them.

The Marriage Is Still Standing

My bride and I are almost complete personality opposites. The difficulties have been real, and after 48 years, neither of us has become the other.

She has not grown into an Inspiring/Dominant personality.

I have not gradually transformed into a Conscientious/Supportive personality, although I have occasionally checked a fact before speaking and would appreciate that being entered into the permanent record.

What has changed is our understanding. What has also changed, by God’s grace, is our character.

Christ has been at the center of our marriage. My bride has extended extraordinary patience and faithfulness. God has exposed selfishness, corrected foolishness, taught us to appreciate what we once resisted, and enabled me to grow up a little.

She can tolerate me now.

The marriage is still standing.

There have been structural repairs, considerable overdue maintenance, and several areas that probably would not pass the original inspection. But the foundation is Christ, and by His grace, the building remains sound.

Your spouse may never think, speak, decide, respond, plan, celebrate, or express love as you do.

That does not necessarily mean something is wrong.

Your spouse’s quietness is not necessarily rejection.

Your spouse’s caution is not necessarily negativity.

Your spouse’s directness is not necessarily anger.

Your spouse’s attention to the task is not necessarily indifference toward you.

Difference is not deficiency.

Stop asking how to make your spouse more responsive to you. Begin asking how understanding your spouse can help you love more wisely.

Do not dramatize the difference.

Do not personalize the difference.

Do not prosecute the difference.

Learn to steward it in love.

Return to Original Article.