The Direction of Your Leadership

Listen to this article (BETA)

Preparing the reader…

Your progress: Not started

Mark Complete Start Over Reset History

▶ Listen

We tend to remember moments.

The sermon that seemed to change everything. The meeting that went terribly wrong. The Sunday when attendance was unusually high. The Sunday when half the church appeared to be somewhere else. The generous gift. The angry email. The ministry launch that exceeded every expectation. The conflict that made us wonder whether anything we had built was going to survive.

Moments are vivid. They demand our attention. They stir our emotions. Because they are happening now, they can feel more important than everything that happened before them.

But moments rarely tell the whole story.

A single photograph may capture something real, but it cannot tell you where someone is going. For that, you need more than a snapshot. You need to see the direction of movement over time.

People consistently overestimate the importance of events and underestimate the importance of trajectories.

A person worries about one bad day of eating while ignoring ten years of habits. A couple becomes frightened by one financial setback but gives little attention to the hundreds of smaller decisions that created their financial direction. A believer becomes consumed by one spiritual failure and overlooks the long work of sanctification God has been accomplishing in him. A church panics over one conflict while ignoring the culture it has quietly cultivated for twenty years.

A leader may also become preoccupied with one mistake, one criticism, one success, or one unusually effective season without asking the more revealing question:

What direction is my leadership moving?

That question is especially important in the church because church leaders are surrounded by moments that can easily be mistaken for evidence of spiritual health. A powerful service can feel like revival. A successful capital campaign can feel like divine approval. Increased attendance can feel like faithfulness. A moving response to an invitation can feel like lasting transformation.

Any of those things may be genuine evidence of God’s work. We should receive them gratefully. But no single event can tell us the entire story.

Jesus did not tell us merely to create moments. He told us to make disciples.

Discipleship is a trajectory.

It is the gradual movement of a person toward Christlikeness through the truth of Scripture, the work of the Holy Spirit, the fellowship of believers, the trials of life, and thousands of acts of trust and obedience. Some of those acts will seem important when they occur. Most will not. Yet God often uses the small, almost invisible choices to shape the direction of a life.

The psalmist said of the righteous man:

“He is like a tree planted by streams of water, yielding its fruit in season, whose leaf does not wither.”
(Psalm 1:3 BSB)

A tree does not become mature during one magnificent afternoon. Its growth is almost impossible to see while you are watching it. Roots deepen quietly. Branches extend slowly. The trunk thickens by increments. Then one day you realize that the sapling you planted years ago has become strong enough to provide shade for others.

That is how much of spiritual growth happens.

It is also how leadership grows—and how leadership deteriorates.

Rarely does a church leader suddenly become arrogant, harsh, isolated, or unaccountable. The movement usually occurs through small allowances. He dismisses one concern without listening. He excuses one unnecessarily sharp response because he is tired. He avoids one difficult apology. He begins to trust his instincts more than the counsel of others. He gradually surrounds himself with people who affirm him and distances himself from those who ask uncomfortable questions.

No one decision appears catastrophic. But the trajectory is becoming dangerous.

The opposite is also true.

A leader becomes gentle through repeated acts of restraint. He becomes wise by listening before answering. He becomes trustworthy by keeping small promises. He becomes humble by acknowledging ordinary mistakes without defending himself. He learns to shepherd people by noticing their burdens, remembering their stories, and caring about what happens to them after the meeting ends.

These actions may never produce a dramatic moment. But they establish a direction.

“Whoever is faithful with very little will also be faithful with much.”
(Luke 16:10 BSB)

We naturally want to do the large thing. We want the breakthrough, the turnaround, the churchwide initiative, the unforgettable sermon, the decisive meeting that resolves years of difficulty. God certainly may work through such moments. But He regularly accomplishes His purposes through faithfulness with “very little.”

The small things are not interruptions to leadership. They are where leadership is formed.

This is why life is shaped far more by direction than by intensity.

Intensity can be impressive. It can also be temporary.

Someone can attend a conference, become deeply convicted, purchase six books, create an ambitious plan, and announce that everything is about to change. For several days, perhaps even several weeks, he is extraordinarily motivated.

Then ordinary life returns.

Transformation is not usually produced by what we do intensely for a few days. It grows from what we do faithfully for a long time.

Paul told Timothy:

“Be diligent in these matters and absorbed in them, so that your progress will be evident to all.”
(1 Timothy 4:15 BSB)

Notice that Paul spoke of progress. Timothy was not expected to arrive instantly at some completed state of spiritual maturity or ministerial skill. He was to continue growing in such a way that the direction of his life could be seen.

That is a wonderfully freeing standard for a Christian leader.

You do not have to demonstrate that you have finished growing. You should be able to demonstrate that you are growing.

Are you becoming more teachable?

Are you listening more carefully?

Are you quicker to repent?

Are you less threatened by disagreement?

Are the people closest to you increasingly able to speak honestly?

Are you becoming more patient with weakness and more courageous in confronting sin?

Is your ministry becoming more dependent upon Christ and less dependent upon your personality, position, or abilities?

The question is not whether there was a bad day somewhere in the story. There will be bad days. The question is whether, over time, the life of Christ is becoming increasingly evident in the way you lead.

This understanding can protect us from two opposite errors.

First, it protects us from despair over a single failure.

Peter denied Christ three times. If we freeze his story in the courtyard, we see a frightened man denying that he even knows Jesus. It is an awful moment. Peter was responsible for it, and the seriousness of his sin should not be minimized.

But the courtyard was not the end of Peter’s story.

Jesus restored him, recommissioned him, and continued His work in him. The man who had once been afraid to identify himself with Christ would later stand publicly and proclaim Him. Peter’s failure was real, but it did not have final authority over the trajectory of his life. Christ did.

This is hope for every leader who has failed.

A failure must be confessed, and its consequences may need to be faced. Harm should be repaired wherever possible. Trust may require time to rebuild. But repentance changes direction. By God’s grace, the worst moment of your leadership does not have to become its final destination.

Second, this understanding protects us from pride over a single success.

A full sanctuary does not necessarily indicate a healthy church. A celebrated sermon does not prove a healthy soul. A growing organization does not guarantee that its leader is growing in love, humility, or holiness.

Success can become a snapshot we use to avoid examining our trajectory.

Leaders sometimes say, in effect, “Look at what is happening through this ministry. Surely that proves we are doing well.” But God is not dazzled by the scale of what we build. He sees the hidden direction of the heart.

“Man looks at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart.”
(1 Samuel 16:7 BSB)

Church leaders must therefore learn to evaluate more than events. We must learn to recognize patterns.

One angry outburst may be an isolated failure followed by genuine repentance. Repeated anger defended as “strong leadership” reveals a trajectory.

One poor decision may result from incomplete information. A continuing refusal to seek counsel reveals a trajectory.

One exhausted season may make a pastor less attentive to his family. A ministry that consistently receives his best while his family receives what remains reveals a trajectory.

One misunderstood conversation may create hurt. A culture in which people are regularly afraid to speak reveals a trajectory.

The wise leader does not explain away patterns by pointing to isolated successes. Nor does he condemn a person solely because of one difficult moment. He looks patiently, honestly, and prayerfully at direction over time.

Jesus said:

“By their fruit you will recognize them.”
(Matthew 7:16 BSB)

Fruit is not produced in an afternoon. It reveals what has been growing.

This kind of thinking changes how church leaders care for people. Instead of asking only, “What happened?” we begin asking, “Where is this leading?”

Where is this marriage headed if nothing changes?

Where will this young leader’s uncorrected habit take him in five years?

What kind of church culture are our repeated decisions producing?

What are our people gradually learning about God from the way we treat them?

What kind of disciples are our ministries actually forming?

What will become normal here if we continue in this direction?

These questions are not intended to make leaders anxious. They help us become faithful stewards. The church belongs to Christ. Its people belong to Christ. Its mission, resources, reputation, and future belong to Christ. Leadership is faithful stewardship applied to people, and stewardship requires us to consider not only what our decisions produce today but where they are taking those entrusted to our care.

Once we recognize an unhealthy trajectory, we often make another mistake: we assume that we must immediately solve the entire problem.

That burden can leave us overwhelmed and motionless.

But most people already know the next right thing to do.

They may not know the next ten things. They may not know how every conversation will go, how every relationship will respond, or how the story will end. But they usually know the next faithful step.

The pastor who has wounded someone may not know how trust will eventually be restored, but he knows he needs to listen and apologize.

The elder board may not know how to transform the entire culture of the church, but it knows that one recurring problem can no longer be ignored.

The ministry leader may not know how to correct years of neglect at home, but he knows he needs to put down his phone, sit with his wife, and ask her how she is doing.

The leader who has become isolated may not know how to rebuild healthy accountability, but he probably knows whom he needs to call.

The believer who feels far from God may not know how to recover all that has been lost, but he knows where his Bible is.

You do not have to finish now, but you do have to start now.

The next right step may seem painfully small compared with the size of the problem. Take it anyway. Direction changes the moment a faithful step is taken.

“Whether you turn to the right or to the left, your ears will hear this command behind you: ‘This is the way. Walk in it.’”
(Isaiah 30:21 BSB)

Walk in it.

Not leap to the end of it. Not solve every possible difficulty before beginning it. Walk in it.

Then take the next step.

This is where intentionality becomes action, action receives accountability, accountability encourages consistency, consistency develops persistence, and persistence produces transformation. No single step appears sufficient by itself. But taken together, those steps establish a new trajectory.

Church leaders should periodically step back from the urgency of weekly ministry and ask what their current patterns are producing. Not only, “Was Sunday successful?” but “What kind of people are we becoming?” Not only, “Did we handle the crisis?” but “What did the way we handled it reinforce?” Not only, “Are people attending?” but “Are people learning to love Christ more deeply, love others more faithfully, and live more wisely?”

We need to ask the same questions personally.

What direction is my heart moving?

What direction is my marriage moving?

What direction are my relationships with fellow leaders moving?

What direction is my private life moving?

If I continue responding to correction as I do now, where will it take me?

If I continue treating people as I do now, what will they eventually believe about leadership—and perhaps about God?

If nothing changes, where will I be five years from now?

Those can be sobering questions. But they are also hopeful because trajectories can change.

By the grace of God, we are not prisoners of yesterday’s direction. Christ calls us to repent, and repentance is not simply feeling badly about where we have been. Repentance is a Spirit-enabled turning—a change of mind, heart, and direction that begins expressing itself through obedience.

You may have had a terrible day. You may have made a serious mistake. Your church may be facing a painful conflict. Your leadership may have drifted in ways you are only beginning to recognize.

Do not ignore the moment. But do not mistake the moment for the entire story.

Bring it into the light. Tell the truth about it. Receive the grace of Christ. Make whatever confession or restitution faithfulness requires. Then ask God to show you the next right thing—and do it.

Your next step will not complete the journey.

But it can change its direction.

And over time, direction changes everything.