Stop Asking God for the Shortcut

Listen to this article (BETA)

Preparing the reader…

Your progress: Not started

Mark Complete Start Over Reset History

▶ Listen

“I just need to know what God wants me to do.”

I understand that sentence. I have said versions of it myself. Most Christians have.

We come to a crossroads. Take the job or stay? Confront the person or wait? Make the investment or keep the money? Move or remain? Say yes or say no? End the relationship or keep working on it? Change churches? Hire the person? Fire the person? Start the ministry? Close the business?

We pray. We read. We ask. And frequently, underneath all of that, we are hoping God will simply tell us the answer.

Preferably soon.

We may not be looking for an easy answer. We may be completely willing to obey a difficult one. We just want a fast one.

We want clarity without the long work of becoming discerning. We want direction without uncertainty. We want the answer before we have had time to examine our motives, seek counsel, understand the circumstances, study the Scriptures, develop patience, or allow God to expose something in us that may be affecting the decision.

But Scripture repeatedly refuses to reduce wisdom to that kind of transaction. God certainly guides His people. He opens and closes doors. He works through circumstances. He answers prayer. He gives counsel through other believers. Above all, He has given us His Word.

But He is doing something larger than getting us through today’s decision.

He is making us wise.

And those are not the same thing.

We Want the Answer. God Wants the Person.

Consider the remarkable sequence in Proverbs that Timothy and Kathy Keller explore in God’s Wisdom for Navigating Life during August 9–16.

The sequence begins with conflict. Proverbs 25 warns us not to rush publicly into a dispute before we understand what actually happened. Proverbs 18 reminds us that unresolved conflict can become fortified until mediation is needed.

Then Proverbs 16:33 takes us somewhere larger:

“The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD.” ~ Proverbs 16:33 BSB

Now we are dealing with providence. Then comes planning:

“The plans of the heart belong to man, but the reply of the tongue is from the LORD.” ~ Proverbs 16:1 BSB

And:

“A man’s heart plans his course, but the LORD determines his steps.” ~ Proverbs 16:9 BSB

Then integrity:

“The integrity of the upright guides them, but the perversity of the faithless destroys them.” ~ Proverbs 11:3 BSB

Then counsel:

“The way of a fool is right in his own eyes, but a wise man listens to counsel.” ~ Proverbs 12:15 BSB

Then diligent planning:

“The plans of the diligent bring plenty, as surely as haste leads to poverty.” ~ Proverbs 21:5 BSB

And finally:

“Commit your works to the LORD and your plans will be achieved.” ~ Proverbs 16:3 BSB

Look at what Scripture just did. It did not give us one technique for discovering God’s will. It gave us a life.

Be humble enough not to assume you know the whole story. Trust God’s providence. Make plans. Develop integrity. Seek counsel. Reject haste. Commit your work to God.

That is wisdom.

God Is the Great Both/And

One of our persistent temptations is to discover one biblical truth and begin using it to flatten every other biblical truth around it.

We learn that God is sovereign. Excellent. Then we begin behaving as though careful planning demonstrates a lack of faith. Or we discover the importance of planning and responsibility, and slowly begin living as though everything depends upon us.

We learn to trust our convictions, then stop listening to counsel. We learn the value of counsel, then become unable to make a decision until everyone agrees with us.

We learn that Scripture is sufficient, then confuse that glorious doctrine with the idea that Scripture gives an explicit answer to every circumstantial decision we will ever face. We learn that God works through providence, then begin interpreting every convenient circumstance as God’s personal endorsement of what we already wanted to do.

We learn to wait on God, then call procrastination “discernment.” We learn courage, then call impatience “boldness.” We learn caution, then call fear “wisdom.”

We discover one true thing about God and begin behaving as though it is the only true thing about God.

That is not maturity.

And in its more rigid forms, it can produce a kind of reductionistic fundamentalism—not necessarily historic theological fundamentalism, but the disposition that says, “I have identified the principle. I have the answer. The matter is settled. There is nothing else to consider.”

But God will not fit inside our favorite principle. He is sovereign AND commands responsibility. He directs our steps AND tells us to plan them. He tells us to trust Him AND to seek wise counsel. He calls us to conviction AND humility.

He commands courage AND patience. He calls us to act AND sometimes commands us to wait. He has revealed truth clearly AND has not revealed everything we would like to know.

The mature Christian learns to not separate what Scripture holds together.

Wisdom Requires Knowing How Little You Know

This may be one of the hardest parts. We want certainty. Proverbs teaches humility.

“The first to state his case seems right until another comes and cross-examines him.” ~ Proverbs 18:17 BSB

That verse ought to be printed above every argument on social media. And perhaps above a few conference-room doors.

The first story usually sounds convincing. Especially when it is our story.

We know what someone said. We know how it affected us. We know what we think they intended. We know the history as we remember it. We know what ought to happen next.

Except sometimes we don’t.

Proverbs 25:8 asks, in effect, What will you do when your neighbor humiliates you because you rushed into a dispute without knowing enough?

Wisdom begins with the possibility: I may not know everything yet.

Jonathan Edwards warned against being “wise in [our] own eyes,” noting Scripture’s severe judgment on spiritual conceit.

That humility is not indecision. It is intellectual and spiritual honesty.

Before deciding, ask: What do I actually know? What am I assuming? Whose account have I not heard? What part of this situation am I emotionally invested in interpreting a certain way? What would I discover if the person who disagrees with me were partly right?

Wisdom does not require us to know everything. It requires us to stop pretending that we do.

Providence Does Not Eliminate Planning

Then we encounter one of the great Both/Ands.

“A man’s heart plans his course, but the LORD determines his steps.” ~ Proverbs 16:9 BSB

Which is it? Do I plan? Or does God direct?

Yes.

That is precisely the point.

The sovereignty of God does not eliminate human responsibility. It gives human responsibility its proper context.

You make the plan. God remains sovereign over the outcome. You study. You prepare. You seek counsel. You count the cost. You make the wisest decision you can make with the information available to you.

And then you acknowledge: I am not sovereign.

Spurgeon beautifully distinguished providence from blind fate. Providence, he argued, is full of wisdom; God’s purposes are not blind wheels spinning without meaning.

That means uncertainty about tomorrow does not mean God has lost control of tomorrow.

It means you were never supposed to control tomorrow.

James says:

“Come now, you who say, ‘Today or tomorrow we will go to this or that city, spend a year there, carry on business, and make a profit.’ You do not even know what will happen tomorrow! What is your life? You are a mist that appears for a little while and then vanishes. Instead, you ought to say, ‘If the Lord is willing, we will live and do this or that.’” ~ James 4:13–15 BSB

Notice again the Both/And. James does not say, “Stop making plans.”

He says, Stop making plans as though you were God.

Character Is Part of Guidance

Proverbs 11:3 may be one of the most important verses in this entire sequence:

“The integrity of the upright guides them, but the perversity of the faithless destroys them.” ~ Proverbs 11:3 BSB

We usually think of guidance as information: God, tell me which direction.

Proverbs introduces something deeper.

Character guides.

Integrity changes what we can see.

A dishonest person can possess all the facts and still reach a corrupt conclusion because he wants the wrong outcome. A proud person can receive excellent counsel and dismiss it. A fearful person can interpret every obstacle as God’s warning to retreat. An ambitious person can interpret every opportunity as God’s invitation to advance.

A resentful person can make vengeance sound remarkably like justice. A controlling person can make domination sound like stewardship.

This is why God’s guidance is not merely something we receive.

It is something we become increasingly able to recognize as He changes who we are.

John Piper makes this point from Romans 12:2. Most of life’s decisions do not come with a biblical list telling us exactly what to choose. The renewed mind increasingly develops the ability not merely to identify what is good but to approve and desire it.

God is not merely filling your spiritual GPS with better directions.

He is transforming the driver.

The Bible Is Not a Magic Eight Ball

There is another temptation when we desperately want clarity. We can misuse Scripture itself.

We open the Bible looking for a sentence that answers the immediate question. Should I take the job? Should I marry this person? Should I move? Should I confront him today?

And sometimes Christians treat the Bible almost like a sanctified fortune-telling device: open it, find a verse, connect it to the decision, and declare that God has spoken.

That is not biblical wisdom.

Psalm 119 says:

“Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path.” ~ Psalm 119:105 BSB

A lamp illuminates the path.

It does not necessarily give you a satellite photograph of the next twenty miles.

Scripture gives us commands, prohibitions, principles, priorities, categories, truth about God, truth about ourselves, truth about people, and the story of redemption. As our minds become saturated with that truth, we become increasingly capable of exercising wisdom where Scripture has not given us an explicit command.

R.C. Sproul made an important distinction when teaching about God’s will: before asking how to know God’s will for our individual lives, we must first understand what we even mean by the will of God.

God’s moral will is not mysterious.

You do not need a sign to determine whether you should lie. You do not need providential confirmation before forgiving. You do not need three counselors to determine whether adultery is permissible. You do not need to “have peace about it” before obeying something God has commanded.

But whether to take Job A or Job B may require wisdom. And sometimes both choices are morally permissible.

That is where mature Christians can become strangely uncomfortable.

We want God to make the choice for us.

Sometimes He gives us something better.

Wisdom with which to choose.

Counsel Is Not an Admission of Weakness

“The way of a fool is right in his own eyes, but a wise man listens to counsel.” ~ Proverbs 12:15 BSB

The fool has something the wise person lacks: complete confidence.

He does not need anyone else. He already understands the situation. He has already reached the conclusion. Now he may ask for counsel—but only from people likely to agree with him.

That is not counsel. That is recruiting witnesses.

Spurgeon once observed that people sometimes decide beforehand what they intend to do and then call agreeable advice “guidance,” while dismissing counsel that contradicts their inclination.

Ouch.

Real counsel creates the possibility that you might change your mind.

Ask people who love God more than they love your approval. Ask people who understand Scripture. Ask people who understand you. Ask someone who is not impressed by you. Ask someone who knows your weaknesses. Ask someone willing to say, “I think you’re wrong.”

Then listen.

Not because counselors are infallible.

Because you aren’t either.

Haste Is Not Faith

“The plans of the diligent bring plenty, as surely as haste leads to poverty.” ~ Proverbs 21:5 BSB

We live in a culture that rewards speed: fast answers, fast decisions, fast growth, fast communication, fast results.

Sometimes speed is necessary.

But urgency has a remarkable ability to impersonate wisdom.

We need to decide. Maybe.

We need to decide today. Why?

Because this opportunity won’t last. Perhaps that is precisely why you should slow down.

Haste narrows our vision. It shortens the counsel process. It magnifies emotion. It makes consequences seem distant and opportunities immediate.

Spurgeon counseled believers facing two morally permissible paths that sometimes the highest wisdom is to wait for providence to make the path clearer rather than rushing ahead.

Waiting is not always wisdom. But neither is moving.

The question is not, “How quickly can I get an answer?”

The question is, “What does faithfulness require here?”

Those are very different questions.

Committing the Work Means Surrendering More Than the Outcome

Then Proverbs brings us here:

“Commit your works to the LORD and your plans will be achieved.” ~ Proverbs 16:3 BSB

It is easy to turn that into: Make plan → ask God to bless plan → proceed confidently.

But committing our work to God means far more.

We commit the purpose. Why am I doing this? We commit the methods. Am I willing to accomplish a good objective only through righteous means? We commit the timing. Am I willing to wait? We commit the cost. What will faithfulness require from me?

We commit the consequences. Am I willing to obey if obedience costs me? And we commit the outcome. What if God does not make this successful in the way I define success?

That last one is difficult.

We often say, “Lord, I give this to You,” while maintaining a remarkably detailed list of acceptable outcomes.

Committing our work to God means placing the whole thing in His hands.

Not asking God to become the executive sponsor of our agenda.

Sometimes the Uncertainty Is the Lesson

We often assume that uncertainty is the problem God needs to solve.

What if He is using it?

What if the unanswered question is exposing your impatience? What if the delay is revealing your need for control? What if conflicting counsel is forcing you deeper into Scripture?

What if the inability to see tomorrow is teaching you to trust the God who already inhabits tomorrow? What if God is less interested, for the moment, in telling you which road to take than in teaching you how to walk with Him on either road?

Spurgeon wrote that God’s providential designs are vast and far-reaching while our own understanding remains fragmentary.

Isaiah had already said it:

“‘For My thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways My ways,’ declares the LORD. ‘For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so My ways are higher than your ways and My thoughts than your thoughts.’” ~ Isaiah 55:8–9 BSB

We do not need to understand everything God is doing in order to trust everything God is.

That may be one of the greatest movements from knowledge toward wisdom.

Wisdom Is Formed Slowly

This is the part we often resist.

Wisdom takes time.

You acquire information quickly. Wisdom is formed through Scripture studied repeatedly, prayers prayed honestly, mistakes admitted humbly, counsel received gratefully, suffering endured faithfully, decisions examined afterward, sin repented of, motives exposed, obedience practiced, and years spent watching the faithfulness of God.

Jonathan Edwards argued that greater knowledge of divine things better equips believers to understand their duty and exercise prudence; zeal without knowledge can actually wound the very cause it intends to serve.

There is no shortcut around formation.

You cannot microwave discernment.

And this is why the Christian who has walked faithfully with God for forty years may sometimes recognize something that the brilliant young Christian with a stack of theology books does not yet see.

The younger believer may know more facts. The older believer has watched those truths collide with life.

Not always. Age alone does not produce wisdom. A person can repeat the same foolishness for forty years.

But truth applied faithfully over time produces something information alone cannot produce.

It produces wisdom.

And Then You Must Decide

Wisdom is not endless analysis.

Eventually, many decisions require action.

You have studied Scripture. You have prayed. You have examined your motives. You have gathered the facts available to you. You have sought wise counsel. You have considered the consequences. You have waited when waiting was appropriate.

Now decide.

And when two choices remain morally legitimate, you may not receive a supernatural certainty that removes all risk.

Make the wisest decision you can.

Then walk.

Trust the providence of God. If you discover that you were wrong, admit it. If circumstances change, adjust. If God closes the door, stop beating on it. If He opens another, consider it.

If the outcome hurts, do not immediately conclude that you missed God’s will. And if the outcome succeeds, do not automatically conclude that your decision was wise.

Results are not the sole measure of faithfulness.

We are responsible for faithful obedience. God remains responsible for providence.

This Changes Leadership

Everything we have said becomes more consequential when other people live downstream from our decisions.

A leader’s impatience does not remain personal. Neither does his arrogance, poor counsel, incomplete information, impulsiveness, fear, or refusal to decide.

People pay for those things.

That is why wise leadership requires more than confidence. Leaders must know what they know and what they do not know. They must seek information from people close enough to the work to see what leadership cannot see. They must create an environment in which people can disagree without being punished.

They must distinguish urgency from haste, conviction from stubbornness, courage from impulsiveness, and patience from avoidance.

And leaders must develop character because character itself becomes part of their guidance system.

The leader whose ambition governs him will consistently interpret information in favor of expansion. The fearful leader will consistently find reasons to delay. The controlling leader will consistently interpret disagreement as disloyalty. The proud leader will consistently underestimate the value of counsel.

The wise leader asks not merely, “What decision should I make?”

He asks, “What kind of person am I becoming as I make decisions?”

Leadership is faithful stewardship applied to people.

That makes wisdom a stewardship responsibility.

The Answer Is Not the Goal

Perhaps that is the great lesson in Keller’s progression through these Proverbs.

We keep asking, What should I do?

God keeps asking: Will you become humble? Will you trust My providence? Will you plan diligently? Will you walk in integrity? Will you seek counsel? Will you reject haste? Will you commit your work to Me? Will you trust Me when you cannot see what comes next?

Those questions are not distractions from guidance.

They are guidance.

Because God is not merely directing your decisions. He is forming your character. He is renewing your mind. He is teaching you wisdom. He is teaching you to recognize what is good.

And ultimately, He is teaching you to trust Him, not merely the answers He gives you.

You may still want the answer quickly. I usually do too.

But perhaps the prayer should become something larger:

Lord, show me what I need to know. Give me the wisdom to recognize what I do not know. Give me the character to obey what You have already made clear. Give me wise people who will tell me the truth. Give me patience when I should wait and courage when I should move. And when I still cannot see the whole road, teach me to trust the One who does.

That is not the shortcut.

It is better. It is wisdom.

In Summary

God’s guidance is not a formula for eliminating uncertainty. Scripture gives us something richer: a life of wisdom formed through truth, character, counsel, planning, providence, patience, prayer, and obedience.

Do not take one true thing about God and use it to eliminate everything Scripture places beside it. Plan and trust. Think and pray. Seek counsel and accept responsibility for deciding. Walk with conviction and remain teachable. Act when faithfulness requires action and wait when wisdom requires patience.

Most importantly, stop treating every difficult decision as though God’s primary objective is to get the correct answer into your hands as quickly as possible.

Sometimes He is doing something much greater…

He is making you into the kind of person who can increasingly recognize wisdom when you see it.

---

Coaching Questions

Coaching Questions are designed to slow us down long enough to examine what we are doing, why we are doing it, and what faithful action should come next. Do not rush through them. Write your answers honestly, identify one specific action, and ask someone you trust to hold you accountable.

1. Where am I demanding immediate clarity when God may be calling me to the slower work of wisdom?
   
2. What biblical truth have I emphasized so strongly that I may be neglecting another truth Scripture asks me to hold alongside it?
   
3. In the decision currently before me, what do I actually know, what am I assuming, and what do I still need to learn?
   
4. Who has permission to challenge my interpretation of God’s guidance—and am I genuinely willing to change my mind?
   
5. Am I primarily asking God to tell me what to do, or am I also asking Him to change the kind of person who is doing the deciding?

---

Quotables

“God usually does not give us wisdom merely by giving us answers. He gives us wisdom by making us wise.”

“We want clarity without the long work of becoming discerning.”

“We discover one true thing about God and begin behaving as though it is the only true thing about God.”

“The mature Christian learns to hold together what Scripture holds together.”

“Wisdom does not require us to know everything. It requires us to stop pretending that we do.”

“Uncertainty about tomorrow does not mean God has lost control of tomorrow. It means you were never supposed to control tomorrow.”

“James does not tell us to stop making plans. He tells us to stop making plans as though we were God.”

“Character itself becomes part of our guidance system.”

“God is not merely filling your spiritual GPS with better directions. He is transforming the driver.”

“A lamp illuminates the path. It does not necessarily give you a satellite photograph of the next twenty miles.”

“Sometimes God does not make the choice for us. He gives us wisdom with which to choose.”

“Real counsel creates the possibility that you might change your mind.”

“Urgency has a remarkable ability to impersonate wisdom.”

“We often say, ‘Lord, I give this to You,’ while maintaining a remarkably detailed list of acceptable outcomes.”

“We do not need to understand everything God is doing in order to trust everything God is.”

“You cannot microwave discernment.”

“Truth applied faithfully over time produces something information alone cannot produce.”

“We are responsible for faithful obedience. God remains responsible for providence.”

“The answer is not the goal. Wisdom is.”

---

Endnotes

1. Timothy Keller with Kathy Keller, God’s Wisdom for Navigating Life: A Year of Daily Devotions in the Book of Proverbs (Viking, 2017), August 9–16. Keller’s August sequence moves from conflict into “Guidance, Planning, and Decision Making,” using Proverbs to explore providence, planning, integrity, counsel, diligence, and commitment to God.
2. Charles H. Spurgeon, “God’s Providence.” Spurgeon distinguishes divine providence from blind fate and emphasizes the wisdom and purpose governing God’s ordering of events.
3. John Piper, “How Do We Know God’s Will?” and “What Is the Will of God and How Do We Know It?” Piper argues from Romans 12:1–2 that the renewed mind develops discernment for the countless decisions for which Scripture does not provide an individualized list of instructions.
4. R.C. Sproul, “Knowing the Will of God,” Ligonier Ministries. Sproul begins the question of knowing God’s will by distinguishing what Christians mean when speaking of the will of God.
5. Charles H. Spurgeon, “The Everlasting Counsellor.” Spurgeon warns against determining beforehand what we want to do and then accepting only the counsel or perceived guidance that agrees with our inclination.
6. Charles H. Spurgeon, “God’s Will About the Future.” Spurgeon argues for prudence and planning while also counseling patience when believers face multiple morally legitimate paths and providence has not yet made the way clear.
7. Charles H. Spurgeon, “God’s Thoughts and Ways Far Above Ours.” Spurgeon emphasizes the vastness of God’s providential purposes compared with the fragmentary nature of human understanding.
8. Jonathan Edwards, The Works of Jonathan Edwards. Edwards argues that knowledge of divine things equips believers for duty, prudence, and discretion, while zeal lacking knowledge can actually harm the cause it intends to serve.
9. Jonathan Edwards, The Works of Jonathan Edwards. Edwards warns against spiritual conceit and connects being wise in one’s own eyes with the biblical condemnation of pride in one’s understanding.
10. Scripture quotations are from the Berean Standard Bible (BSB).

---