Self-Control: Learning to Do What You Have Decided to Do

Listen to this article (BETA)

Preparing the reader…

Your progress: Not started

Mark Complete Start Over Reset History

▶ Listen

Have you ever made a decision you were absolutely convinced was the right one, only to discover a few days later that you were not doing what you had decided to do?

Perhaps you decided to begin exercising, spend more time with your family, read your Bible every morning, or finally tackle a project that has been waiting patiently for your attention. You considered the benefits, made a sincere commitment, and may even have told someone about your plans.

Then Monday arrived.

The alarm went off, the bed was warm, and suddenly the exercise program that seemed so reasonable on Sunday evening did not seem quite as urgent. You still believed exercising was important. You simply believed that another thirty minutes of sleep was important, too. At least for the moment.

I suspect most of us recognize ourselves somewhere in that picture. We genuinely want the outcomes we have committed ourselves to pursuing. Yet wanting something and doing what is necessary to accomplish it are two very different things. That uncomfortable distance between our intentions and our actions is where self-control becomes so important.

When we hear the words self-control, we usually think about resisting something. We picture a person refusing another piece of cake, controlling his temper, resisting temptation, or choosing not to say something he will later regret. Those are certainly expressions of self-control, but they represent only half of what it requires. Sometimes self-control means not doing what we want to do. At other times, it means doing what we do not particularly want to do because we have already determined that doing it is right, necessary, or worthwhile.

Self-control is not merely the ability to stop doing what we should not do. It is also the ability to do what we have determined we ought to do.

That second dimension deserves considerably more attention than we usually give it.

Self-Control Is About Direction, Not Merely Restraint

Consider two fathers who love their families and genuinely want to become better husbands and dads.

The first father struggles with his temper. When he is tired or frustrated, his words become unnecessarily harsh. He recognizes the damage this causes and wants to respond with greater patience and gentleness. The second father rarely loses his temper, but he is frequently distracted. He intends to spend more time with his children, listen to them, and become more involved in their lives. Somehow, however, his work, phone, hobbies, and other responsibilities continually receive the attention he intended to give his family.

Which father needs self-control?

Both of them.

The first must learn to restrain a harmful response, while the second must learn to initiate and sustain a beneficial one. Their difficulties look different, but both involve bringing their behavior into agreement with what they know they ought to do.

We can become so focused on avoiding wrongdoing that we overlook our responsibility to pursue what is good. A person may avoid many destructive behaviors and still neglect important responsibilities. Another may be exceptionally productive while leaving a trail of damaged relationships because he has never learned to govern his words or emotions.

Biblical self-control involves both dimensions. We must learn to say no to what is wrong and yes to what is right.

Why Knowing Better Does Not Always Produce Doing Better

One of the more fascinating things about human behavior is how often we know precisely what we should do and still fail to do it. We understand that exercise benefits our health, marriages require attention, and difficult responsibilities seldom become easier because we ignore them.

Why, then, do we struggle to act upon what we know? Because knowing what is best does not eliminate our competing desires.

We want to be healthier, but we also want to sleep. We want stronger relationships, but we would rather avoid uncomfortable conversations. We want to accomplish something meaningful, but our phones, the television, or a dozen other distractions offer something more immediately enjoyable.

Immediate rewards have a persuasive advantage. The comfort of remaining in bed is available right now, while the benefits of exercising may take months to become visible. Avoiding a difficult conversation brings immediate relief, while resolving the underlying problem requires effort and perhaps some emotional discomfort.

We make many of our best decisions while considering the future, but we must carry them out while experiencing the present. The present can be remarkably persuasive!

Self-control helps us honor a thoughtful decision even when our immediate feelings argue for something else. Our emotions are not necessarily wrong or unimportant, but neither should every passing desire be allowed to overrule what we have determined is worthwhile.

Self-Control, Discipline, Consistency, and Persistence

We frequently use these four words as though they mean essentially the same thing. They are closely related, but each contributes something different to meaningful change.

Self-control is the capacity to govern our behavior, choosing what is right or worthwhile rather than surrendering to whichever desire happens to be strongest.

Self-discipline is the deliberate training and structure through which we exercise that capacity. It includes the routines, commitments, and practices that help us follow through.

Consistency develops when those actions become a dependable pattern rather than something we do occasionally.

Persistence enables us to continue when the work becomes difficult, progress slows, or circumstances interrupt our plans.

Think about someone learning to play the piano. Self-control gets him onto the piano bench when he would rather do something else. Discipline establishes a practice routine, and consistency means he follows it regularly. Persistence keeps him practicing when he encounters a difficult passage that refuses to cooperate, no matter how many times he plays it.

As a musician, I can assure you that the difficult passage does not ordinarily surrender simply because you have become irritated with it! Progress comes through thoughtful practice, repeated effort, and a willingness to continue when improvement is not immediately apparent.

What initially requires considerable effort can gradually become part of how we live. The choices that once demanded deliberate attention can become established practices, and those practices can support a lifetime of faithful action.

Self-Control Is Both a Gift and a Responsibility

For Christians, self-control is more than a useful skill for accomplishing personal goals. Scripture identifies it as part of the fruit of the Spirit.

In Galatians 5:22–23, Paul includes self-control alongside love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, and gentleness. These are not merely admirable behaviors we manufacture through sufficient determination. They are qualities of character the Holy Spirit produces in those who belong to Christ.

That raises an interesting question. If self-control is produced by the Holy Spirit, why does Scripture repeatedly command us to exercise it?

In 2 Peter 1:5–8, Peter urges believers to make every effort to grow in qualities that include knowledge, self-control, perseverance, godliness, brotherly kindness, and love. Paul uses the illustration of an athlete in 1 Corinthians 9:24–27, describing purposeful training in pursuit of a worthwhile goal.

Are we supposed to depend upon God or discipline ourselves?

The biblical answer is both, although not as two independent sources of power. Philippians 2:12–13 explains the relationship beautifully. Paul calls believers to work out their salvation precisely because God is at work within them, shaping both their willing and their acting according to His good purpose.

God’s work does not make our obedience unnecessary. His work makes our obedience possible.

We neither manufacture spiritual maturity through determination alone nor wait passively for obedience to happen. God’s gracious work enables the faithful response He commands.

This also protects us from confusing discipline with godliness. A person can be remarkably disciplined while pursuing selfish or destructive objectives. Christian self-control is not simply learning how to get what we want. It is learning to govern ourselves in ways that honor God, fulfill our responsibilities, and demonstrate love toward others.

Decide What You Are Actually Going to Do

Now that we understand what self-control involves, how do we begin developing it?

One of the most practical steps is to stop relying on vague intentions.

Consider the difference between saying, “I really need to exercise more,” and saying, “On Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, I will walk for thirty minutes immediately after getting up.” The first expresses a desire, while the second establishes a specific commitment.

The distinction may seem small, but research suggests it can make a meaningful difference.

Psychologists Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran examined 94 independent tests of a planning method called implementation intentions. Their research found that connecting an intended behavior with a specific situation or opportunity improved the likelihood of accomplishing the goal.¹

In everyday language, we are deciding what we will do, when we will do it, and under what circumstances we will begin.

This matters because a decision that must be made again every morning is vulnerable to whatever we happen to feel that morning. Establishing the action and its timing removes one opportunity to negotiate ourselves out of doing it.

Of course, making a plan does not guarantee that we will follow it. We still need self-control. But a specific plan gives us something concrete to act upon instead of another good intention and the hope that tomorrow will somehow be different.

Begin Before You Feel Ready

There is a common assumption that motivation must come before action. We imagine that once we feel sufficiently inspired, enthusiastic, or determined, we will finally begin doing what we have been postponing.

Sometimes that happens. More often than we might expect, however, the relationship works in the opposite direction.

Psychologist Jerome Bruner is credited with an observation that captures this principle particularly well: *”You are more likely to act yourself into feeling than to feel yourself into action.”*²

I have used that observation in my own teaching because it describes something most of us have experienced. We begin a responsibility reluctantly, perhaps even grumbling a little, only to discover that once we are engaged, the work becomes easier and our motivation increases.

Consider someone who wants to write a book. He may spend months thinking about it, discussing it with friends, researching the subject, and imagining how satisfying it will be to hold the finished book in his hands. All of that may be useful preparation, but at some point he must actually sit down and write. Books are not written merely by thinking about writing them, however enthusiastic those thoughts may be.

That is why I frequently remind people, “You do not have to finish now, but you do have to start now.”

We sometimes make beginning unnecessarily difficult by imagining the entire task at once. Thirty minutes of exercise feels overwhelming, so we do nothing. A difficult relationship needs attention, but we cannot imagine resolving every problem in one conversation, so we never make the first phone call.

What if we began with ten minutes of exercise or one thoughtful conversation? We would not be abandoning the larger objective. We would be taking the first responsible step toward it.

Starting small is not an excuse for remaining small. It is a practical way to overcome the resistance that prevents us from starting at all.

Consistency Is Built Through Repetition

Once we begin, the next challenge is continuing. Initially, a new behavior may require considerable conscious effort. We must remember our commitment, arrange our schedule, and resist competing desires. Over time, however, repeated behaviors can become more familiar and increasingly automatic.

Health psychology researcher Phillippa Lally and colleagues at University College London studied this process by asking 96 volunteers to repeat an everyday behavior in a consistent setting over twelve weeks.³ Their findings challenged the familiar claim that habits form in exactly twenty-one days. Among participants whose data could be modeled, the estimated time to approach their individual level of automaticity ranged from 18 to 254 days.

That is quite a range, isn’t it? Apparently, some habits are considerably less cooperative than others.

The researchers also found that missing a single opportunity did not materially disrupt the habit-formation process. That is encouraging for those of us who have occasionally missed a planned activity and then felt tempted to abandon the entire effort.

Consistency does not require a flawless record. It requires returning to the intended behavior and continuing to practice it.

Suppose you intend to exercise four mornings each week but miss Wednesday because an unexpected responsibility requires your attention. You have not necessarily failed in your commitment to physical fitness. The more important question is what happens Thursday or Friday.

A temporary interruption becomes a larger problem when we allow it to become permission to stop altogether. We should learn from interruptions, adjust when necessary, and continue rather than treating every imperfect week as evidence that the entire effort has failed.

There is also an important distinction between forming a habit and developing Christian character. Repetition can make a behavior easier, but spiritual maturity involves more than efficient routines. A habit may support faithfulness; it cannot replace the heart from which genuine faithfulness flows.

Prepare for the Moment When You Would Rather Quit

One of the most useful discoveries in the study of self-control is that successful people do not always depend upon winning a dramatic battle of willpower at the last possible moment. Often, they make wise decisions before that moment arrives.

Psychologist Angela Duckworth, philosopher Tamar Szabó Gendler, and psychologist James Gross have examined how people use their circumstances to support long-term goals.⁴ Rather than continually exposing themselves to distractions and hoping their determination will prevail, they arrange their environments to make worthwhile actions easier.

If you intend to exercise in the morning, prepare your clothing the evening before. If you need uninterrupted time to study or write, establish a place where distractions are less likely. If your marriage needs more intentional attention, reserve time together before your calendar fills with everything else that wants a piece of your life.

There is no particular virtue in making obedience unnecessarily difficult.

Proverbs 22:3 teaches that the prudent recognize danger and take precautions, while the simple continue without considering the consequences. The proverb addresses prudence broadly, but the principle certainly applies here. If we already know what is likely to interfere with a worthwhile commitment, why wait until it happens before deciding what to do?

Suppose you have committed to walking each morning, but rain frequently interrupts your plans. Establish an alternative in advance. When it rains, exercise indoors. The objective remains the same, even though the circumstances require a different approach.

Sometimes developing self-control means becoming stronger in a difficult moment. At other times, it means becoming wiser before the difficult moment arrives.

Pay Attention to What You Actually Do

There is a difference between believing we are making progress and knowing that we are making progress. Our impressions are not always reliable, particularly when we genuinely want to believe we are doing better.

Psychologist Benjamin Harkin and colleagues examined 138 studies involving 19,951 participants and found that encouraging people to monitor their progress improved goal attainment.⁵ The effects were stronger when progress was recorded or reported to others.

This does not mean we need a spreadsheet for every responsibility or a chart documenting every good deed. It means that periodically examining what we actually do can help us recognize whether our behavior agrees with our intentions.

If you have committed to walking four mornings each week, keep a simple record. If you want to spend more intentional time with your children, occasionally ask yourself whether that is really happening. If you are working to control angry responses, consider the situations in which you responded well and those in which you did not.

We must also remember that what we measure is not always what matters most. A husband might faithfully record a weekly date night while remaining emotionally distant from his wife. A leader might complete every task on his calendar while neglecting the people he is responsible for leading.

Measurement can tell us whether an action occurred. Wisdom helps us determine whether that action is accomplishing something worthwhile.

When You Fail, Begin Again

Sooner or later, everyone who seriously attempts to develop self-control will experience failure. We will procrastinate, speak carelessly, neglect a responsibility, or choose immediate comfort over a commitment we genuinely intended to keep.

What happens next matters enormously. Some people respond by explaining away their behavior. Others become so discouraged that they abandon the effort entirely. Neither response helps us grow, because one avoids responsibility while the other treats failure as though it were final.

I have often reminded people that explanation is not exoneration. Understanding why we failed can be extremely helpful, but understanding alone does not remove our responsibility to respond appropriately.

For Christians, this includes recognizing when our failure involves sin, confessing it, seeking forgiveness where others have been harmed, and returning to faithful obedience. First John 1:9 reminds us of God’s faithfulness in forgiving confessed sin. His mercy does not make repentance unnecessary; it gives us confidence to approach Him rather than hide from Him.

At the same time, not every interruption is a moral failure. Illness, emergencies, changing responsibilities, and ordinary human limitations sometimes require us to adjust our plans. Wisdom helps us distinguish between legitimate limitations and convenient excuses without treating every disruption as either unavoidable or unforgivable.

When you fail to follow through on a commitment, ask yourself two questions: What actually prevented me? and What should I do differently next time? Perhaps you need a more realistic plan, a different environment, encouragement, or someone who will hold you accountable. Perhaps you simply need to stop negotiating with yourself and do what you have already decided ought to be done.

A missed opportunity need not become an abandoned responsibility. Learn what you can, make the necessary correction, and continue.

The Ordinary Moments Matter Most

We naturally admire remarkable demonstrations of discipline. We appreciate the athlete who trains for years, the musician who practices thousands of hours, and the entrepreneur who perseveres through enormous difficulties. Yet most of us will exercise self-control far more frequently in ordinary situations that attract little attention.

It is the husband who puts down his phone because his wife is speaking. It is the mother who responds patiently to another question when she is already exhausted. It is the employee who completes an important responsibility without being reminded, the leader who addresses a difficult problem rather than allowing it to grow, and the Christian who opens his Bible when a dozen other activities are competing for his attention.

None of these actions is particularly dramatic. Some may not even be noticed by anyone else. Yet these are the decisions through which our character, relationships, and responsibilities are shaped over time.

A single thoughtful conversation may not transform a marriage. One morning of exercise may not dramatically improve our health. An hour of study will not make us an expert. But repeated faithful actions can produce changes that occasional bursts of enthusiasm never will.

Self-control helps us move from what we value to what we practice.

The Goal Is Faithfulness, Not Merely Achievement

There is one final distinction we must not overlook. Self-control is a means, not the ultimate destination.

A person can become remarkably disciplined while pursuing objectives that do not deserve his devotion. A leader may build an impressive organization while neglecting his family. A Christian may maintain a rigorous schedule of spiritual activities while failing to demonstrate love, patience, humility, and kindness.

The ability to accomplish something does not necessarily mean we ought to accomplish it.

For believers, the ultimate purpose of self-control is not self-exaltation but faithful stewardship. God has given us time, abilities, opportunities, relationships, and responsibilities. We are called to use them wisely, remembering that what has been placed in our care ultimately belongs to Him.

That changes the question we ought to be asking. Rather than measuring ourselves solely by how much we accomplish, we must consider whether our actions reflect the responsibilities God has given us and the character He is producing within us.

Perhaps the most useful question, then, is not simply, “Do I have self-control?” A better question might be, “Am I increasingly doing what I know I ought to do, even when I would rather do something else?”

Think about something worthwhile that you have wanted to accomplish but have repeatedly postponed. Perhaps it is a responsibility you have neglected, a relationship that needs your attention, or a commitment you keep promising yourself you will begin. You may not need another inspirational speech about its importance. You may simply need to decide what you are going to do, determine when you are going to do it, and begin.

You will not do it perfectly, and some days will be harder than others. When those days arrive, depend upon the God who is at work within you, learn what you need to learn, and continue in faithfulness.

Applied knowledge repeated consistently becomes transformation.

So, what is that one thing you already know you ought to do?

You do not have to finish now, but you do have to start now.

---

Summary

Self-control is not merely the ability to resist harmful behavior. It is also the ability to begin and continue worthwhile action, particularly when our immediate desires compete with what we have already determined is right.

Self-control governs our choices, discipline provides deliberate training and structure, consistency establishes a dependable pattern, and persistence helps us continue through difficulty. Specific plans, repeated behaviors, thoughtfully arranged environments, and honest progress monitoring can help us put these qualities into practice.

For Christians, self-control is part of the fruit produced by the Holy Spirit. We do not manufacture spiritual maturity through determination alone, nor do we wait passively for obedience to happen. God’s gracious work enables our responsible participation, and the ultimate goal is faithful stewardship rather than achievement for its own sake.

Self-control helps us move from what we value to what we practice.

---

Five Coaching Questions

1. Where is the greatest distance between what you believe you ought to do and what you are actually doing? What responsibility, relationship, or worthwhile commitment comes to mind first?
2. What competing desire most often persuades you to abandon that commitment? Is it comfort, distraction, fear, discouragement, or something else? How could you prepare for that moment before it arrives?
3. What specific action will you take, and when will you take it? Describe a realistic first step rather than another general intention.
4. How will you respond when your consistency is interrupted? What would help you distinguish a legitimate limitation from an excuse, make an appropriate correction, and begin again?
5. How does your goal reflect faithful stewardship rather than merely personal achievement? Who will be loved, served, or benefited as you grow in self-control?

---

Endnotes

1. Peter M. Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran, “Implementation Intentions and Goal Achievement: A Meta-analysis of Effects and Processes,” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 38 (2006): 69–119. The meta-analysis examined 94 independent tests and found a meaningful positive effect of implementation intentions on goal attainment. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(06)38002-1

2. The statement “You are more likely to act yourself into feeling than to feel yourself into action” is commonly attributed to psychologist Jerome Bruner. Royce White also used the attribution in Positive Accountability (2014), and John C. Maxwell attributed it to Bruner in Failing Forward (2000). An original publication by Bruner establishing the quotation has not been verified. It is therefore identified in the article as an attribution, not a confirmed direct quotation from a specific Bruner publication.

3. Phillippa Lally, Cornelia H. M. van Jaarsveld, Henry W. W. Potts, and Jane Wardle, “How Are Habits Formed: Modelling Habit Formation in the Real World,” European Journal of Social Psychology 40 (2010): 998–1009. The study followed 96 participants and found substantial variation in the time required for behaviors to approach automaticity; a missed opportunity did not necessarily undermine the process. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.674

4. Angela L. Duckworth, Tamar Szabó Gendler, and James J. Gross, “Situational Strategies for Self-Control,” Perspectives on Psychological Science 11, no. 1 (2016): 35–55. The authors examine strategies that influence situations and environments before temptation or conflict reaches its strongest point. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4736542/

5. Benjamin Harkin et al., “Does Monitoring Goal Progress Promote Goal Attainment? A Meta-Analysis of the Experimental Evidence,” Psychological Bulletin 142, no. 2 (2016): 198–229. The analysis included 138 studies with 19,951 participants and found that progress monitoring improved goal attainment, with stronger effects when progress was recorded or publicly reported. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000025

---